Plaster Repair Questions Answered
Plaster repair questions we hear every week across the Illawarra, answered straight by the plasterer who does the work.
When can a crack just be patched?
A hairline crack that opens and closes with the seasons, or a straight crack along a plasterboard join, can usually be patched once the cause has settled. A crack wider than 3 mm, one running diagonally from a door or window corner, one that keeps coming back, or one where one side sits proud of the other means something is moving. Doors and windows suddenly sticking, step cracks in brickwork, a sagging ceiling or cornice separating from the wall are reasons to get a builder or structural engineer before plastering.
What do people get wrong with DIY plaster patching?
Filling a deep hole without backing and tape so it cracks, using fine surface filler for big holes, overfilling and then sanding for hours, not fixing the cause of a movement crack, and painting before the compound is fully dry.
When is patching worth it, and when should a ceiling be replaced?
Patch when the damage is under about a third of the ceiling, the surrounding plaster is sound, there is no sag, it is dry, the cornice is intact and it is standard plasterboard. Replace when it is sagging, soft or crumbling, has several failed patches, covers more than a third of the ceiling, is failing lath-and-plaster, has a separated cornice, or has been wet repeatedly.
How can you tell if a ceiling stain is still wet?
Not by eye. A wet stain is darker with a moving edge, soft plaster and a cool feel; an old one is hard and chalky with a crisp tide mark. We confirm with a moisture meter against a dry part of the same ceiling and a thermal camera, then mark and date the extent.
What is the difference between a level 4 and level 5 finish?
Level 4 is the standard trade finish under AS/NZS 2589, flat under normal light with flat or low-sheen paint. Level 5 adds a skim coat over the whole surface for raking light, gloss or dark paint, such as long hallways with a window at the end or ceilings under a skylight.
When can I paint new plaster?
Wait at least 24 hours, longer in cold or humid weather. Use a good plasterboard sealer or 3-in-1 prep coat (mould-resistant in bathrooms and kitchens), then two coats of low-sheen or bathroom-grade acrylic. Avoid cheap PVA sealer and never put gloss straight onto new set.
How long should I wait after a leak before repairing the ceiling?
Fix the leak first, then let the ceiling dry, usually three to seven days with good ventilation. Remove wet insulation. If the ceiling is bulging or water is pooling above, make it safe straight away and repair once dry. Stopping or painting over damp plaster traps moisture and leads to mould and bubbling. Sewage leaks or heavy mould need advice before anything is covered.
Is a sagging ceiling dangerous?
It can be. Call straight away if it is visibly bulging, the cornice has separated, plaster is cracking and dropping, it is stained and soft, it creaks when pressed, or water is pooling or dripping. Keep the room clear until it has been made safe.
What should I do if I think my ceiling has asbestos?
Do not drill, cut, sand or break it. Older Illawarra homes may have fibro sheeting, ceiling tiles, cornice or joint compound containing asbestos. Get it tested and, if needed, removed by a licensed asbestos removalist before any plastering.
What should a good plastering quote include?
What is included (removal, re-sheet, tape, stop, sand, rubbish), what is excluded (paint, asbestos, roof repairs, structural work), access assumptions, whether GST is included, the number of visits, expected drying time, and any minimum charge or after-hours surcharge.
How do I prepare for the plasterer?
Clear about 1.5 metres around the work area, move fragile items and pictures, secure pets, leave parking and power available, cover anything you cannot move, and tell us about stairs, gates or steep driveways. We use plastic sheeting, drop sheets and a vacuum, but fine dust can still reach the next room.
Patch or replace: a quick guide
| Situation | Usually patch | Usually replace |
|---|---|---|
| Small doorknob hole | Yes | No |
| Fist-sized hole | Yes | No |
| Cracked ceiling joint under 3 m | Yes | Only if recurring |
| Water damage under 1 m², dry | Yes | No |
| Water damage over 2 m² | Maybe | Often |
| Sagging ceiling | No | Yes, or re-fix |
| Old lath-and-plaster with multiple failures | No | Yes |
| Cornice separated | Repair first | If widespread |
| Multiple failed patches | No | Yes |
After a leak: the practical timeline
| When | What to do |
|---|---|
| Day 1 | Fix the leak and take photos. Keep the room clear if the ceiling is bulging. |
| Day 1 to 2 | Remove wet insulation and any soft plaster. Run a fan or dehumidifier. |
| Day 3 to 7 | Check it is dry. A moisture meter is best; plaster should not feel cold or damp. |
| Day 5 to 10 | Patch or re-sheet once dry. |
| After plastering | Wait until the compound is fully dry, then prime and paint. |
Do not paint over a damp stain, patch a live leak, or assume a brown stain is just cosmetic.